Paige DeSorbo Reacts to Craig’s Romance With Natalie Buffett

4

Credit: Instagram

Paige DeSorbo appeared to address Craig Conover’s reported new romance with Natalie Buffett, hinting that every guy she’s dated “immediately dates a blonde” after their breakup.

At the end of 2024, the Summer House star shared that she and Craig parted ways. Shortly after, Craig alleged that Paige had instigated it and had taken him by surprise, as he had recently bought her a ring.

Months later, a report surfaced that Craig is getting serious with his alleged new girlfriend, Natalie. According to photos, she has dirty blonde hair.

“I’m not kidding: Every guy I’ve ever dated, I feel like, immediately dates a blonde after. And I’m like, ‘Oh, you didn’t get me at all,’” said Paige on her Giggly Squad podcast, suggesting that this “solidified” that they weren’t supposed to be together.

“I kind of like it,” she added, “cause I’m like, ‘Oh yeah … We weren’t for each other. We didn’t mesh.’”

Paige also shared two stories about blonde people.

“When I was modeling and if I didn’t get a certain job … if I were to ever ask my mom like, ‘Hey, did I like book that commercial or did I book whatever?’ And she would say, ‘No, they went with a blonde,’” recalled Paige. “In my head it would register as like, ‘Oh, well I’m not blonde so, like, I didn’t even compete against that girl.’”

Another of Paige’s stories “went back even further.”

“When I was younger, my dad owned a car wash. And one day, me and my mom went to this car wash, and he had candy on the side of the car wash, and he would give it to little kids, and one day I saw my dad talking to this little girl … [who was] with her mom,” said Paige. “My dad’s talking to this little girl, and I guess I had just never seen my dad interact with a child other than myself. So I was, as you can imagine, taken aback. And I was like, ‘Who is that girl?’”

“It truly traumatized me,” she went on. “I don’t know if I thought my dad was going to go with this little girl and be her dad or what I cooked up in my head, but like it’s deep-rooted, my thing with blondes.”