The Secret Circle has ended, but the show’s stars including Britt Robertson, Thomas Dekker and Phoebe Tonkin have remained on our screens.
The CW initially found success in 2009 when it adapted L.J. Smith‘s The Vampire Diaries book series. Two years later, the network expanded with Smith’s The Secret Circle. Set in the fictional town of Chance Harbor, Washington, the series focused on Cassie Blake who — after moving to town following her mother’s murder — discovered she is a hereditary witch and became the sixth member of a secret coven.
Despite becoming The CW’s third-highest rated performer, The Secret Circle was canceled after one season. Fans attempted to bring the show back with various campaigns but The Secret Circle wasn’t brought back — yet.
Creator Andrew Miller has teased where he would have taken the story if given the chance.
“A movie, a play, a commercial campaign for crystals, you name it,” Miller told Book Trib in 2012. “[Production company] Alloy [Entertainment] asked me if I had any interest in trying a lower budget version of the show that could be done on Netflix and I pitched them an idea I really loved and would’ve done in a second.”
He continued: “Following [Shelley Hennig]’s Diana after the finale to California, where she was alone and confused and struggling between her good nature and the dark magic she just accessed to kill her father. My dream was to set her life up in California, then bring in [Phoebe Tonkin]’s Faye to mess it up.”
The Secret Circle ended up one of many short-lived shows on The CW but the cast has continued to document their reunions over the years. Keep scrolling to see where the cast of The Secret Circle is now:
![Marciano Brunette Says He & Jessi Ngatikaura Texted Days Before Premiere and Jordan “Call[ed] Production” on Them](https://realityblurb.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/Marciano-Brunette-and-Jessi-Ngatikaura.jpg "Marciano Brunette Says He & Jessi Ngatikaura Texted Days Before Premiere and Jordan “Call[ed] Production” on Them")
