Law & Order – “Ride or Die” – Review: Cutthroat

The Case

Ride or Die, the latest episode of Law & Order, is a rare thing: a murder mystery where the metaphor doesn’t just sit in the subtext — it bleeds into the text. “Cutthroat” isn’t just the vibe of a toxic beauty pageant; it’s the manner of death. Katie Harrington (Charlotte Jane), pageant judge and rising news station star, gets her throat slit in a world where competition isn’t just fierce — it’s fatal.
Lt. Jessica Brady (Maura Tierney) and Det. Vincent Riley (Reid Scott) move through suspects with the brisk rhythm of a runway walk:

“Ride or Die”– LAW & ORDER, Pictured: (l-r) Reid Scott as
Detective Vincent Riley, Odelya Halevi as A.D.A. Samantha Maroun. Photo by:
Virginia Sherwood/NBC@2026 NBCUniversal Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. 
• Kailani Arizaga (Nyah Juliano) — never interested in winning a beauty pageant, a dying industry.

• Alexander Rublev (Jack Rasmussen) — obsessed suitor, but too easy.

• Jasmin Hernandez (Kat Pena) — threatened Katie, but for reasons that had nothing to do with mascara or tiaras.

Jasmin’s “threat” was tied to a girl gang news segment Katie produced. The segment misidentified a neighborhood man as a gang recruiter, and Jasmin became the community’s scapegoat — a “rat.” When Jasmin stands up during questioning wearing the same hat the killer wore, the detectives ask the right question: Where did she get that hat? Answer: Ann Merrick (Kelli Williams), Katie’s boss and mentor turned nemesis.

Cutthroat, right?

“Ride or Die”– LAW & ORDER, Pictured: Tom Galantich as
Thomas Williams. Photo by: Virginia Sherwood/NBC@2026 NBCUniversal Media, LLC.
All Rights Reserved. 

Mentor, Mentee, and the Murder Motive

Ann Merrick is arrested, and her attorney Abby Donahue (Alanna Ubach) mounts an Extreme Emotional Disturbance (EED) defense. The theory: Katie betrayed Ann professionally — a workplace infidelity, so devastating it triggered a psychological break.

The backstory is brutal:

• Katie lied to the station executive about the gang segment error.

• An email surfaces showing she took responsibility privately but blamed Ann publicly.

• Ann’s 22-year contract wasn’t renewed; her path to national anchor was derailed.

• Katie got her job.

Cutthroat, right?

“Ride or Die”– LAW
& ORDER, Pictured: (l-r) Kelli Williams as Ann Merrick, Reid Scott as Detective Vincent
Riley, Maura Tierney as Lieutenant Jessica Brady. Photo by: Virginia
Sherwood/NBC@2026
NBCUniversal Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
The defense even brings in an expert on female workplace trauma, likening the mentor mentee rupture to a cheating spouse. DA Baxter (Tony Goldwyn) quips he didn’t know this was a field of study — and ADA Samantha Maroun (Odelya Halevi) weaponizes that skepticism beautifully.

Samantha’s Cross: A Surgical Strike

Maroun dismantles the expert with two clean cuts:

1. She’s never testified before, and

2. No female mentor mentee murder has ever been exonerated using an EED defense. 

Maroun’s logic lands hard: If this defense has never succeeded before, how can it be considered reasonable?

The Cracks in Ann Merrick’s Saintly Image

Ann Merrick testifies about her lifelong commitment to mentoring women. The jury softens. Samantha senses it. Then Ann’s attorney blindsides ADA Maroun by introducing Katie’s confession email — undermining the testimony of the station’s chief executive, Thomas Williams (Tom Galantich), and making Ann appear even more sympathetic.

When Maroun confronts Abby, Abby shrugs: “I’m trying to win a trial here.”

By hiding evidence? Samantha fires back. Cutthroat, right?

Maroun keeps digging. She finds Sarah Chase (Whitney Kimball Long), a former Merrick mentee who reveals the truth: Ann was a great mentor — until Sarah got a job Ann wanted. Ann threatened to kill her.
Cutthroat, right?

“Ride or Die”– LAW & ORDER, Pictured: Alanna Ubach as Atty. Abigail
Donahue. Photo by: Will Hart/NBC@2026 NBCUniversal Media, LLC. All Rights
Reserved. 
The Mentor Debt and the Moral Line

Abby visits Samantha Maroun at home — a boundary crossing move dripping with emotional manipulation. She frames the plea as a feminist cause, then twists the knife:

“You owe me. I did you a favor. Now I’m asking for one.”

It’s quid pro quo disguised as sisterhood.

Maroun asks Baxter if a mentor has ever demanded repayment. His answer is simple:
No mentor worth anything ever would.

The Choice

In court, the judge asks for the prosecution’s next witness. ADA Maroun hesitates. The whole episode hangs on this pause. Does she call Sarah Chase, knowing it will damage her relationship with Abby?
She stands. She calls Sarah.

The jury convicts Ann Merrick of second-degree murder. Outside the courtroom, Samantha rushes to Abby, asking for a chance to explain. Abby cuts her off: “We’re done.”

Cutthroat, right?

Simultaneously, Baxter arrives at Maroun’s side, praising her. She barely hears him.

“Ride or Die”– LAW
& ORDER, Pictured: (l-r) Odelya Halevi as A.D.A. Samantha Maroun,
Tony Goldwyn as District Attorney Nicholas Baxter. Photo by: Will Hart/NBC@2026
NBCUniversal Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Verdict on the Episode

The EED defense is overwrought and under explained, but the emotional architecture — mentor debts, female ambition, weaponized loyalty — is sharp and thematically coherent. A solid episode with a strong spine, even if the psychological theory wobbles.

Is Abby’s fury at Samantha any different from Ann’s fury at Katie — or is it the same wound wearing a different suit? Share your thoughts in the comments. 

Overall Rating: 6 out of 10

Lynette Jones